TOWING: Britain’s most reliable cars for 2009

Reliability. It’s the last thing a caravan owner needs at the back of their mind when driving a towcar. When pulling a caravan however large or small, an owner needs to be sure their car will last the trip. Dependability is essential for a good towing workhorse, yet despite modern car testing methods too often the biggest marques achieve surprisingly low scores in tests.

When buying a new car in today’s market, it pays in the long run to buy Japanese. That’s according to the latest Which Car? survey for 2009 in which the Honda Accord has scored an extraordinary 99% rating.

Seven of the top 10 new cars are Japanese, with another Honda (the Jazz) coming in second place. It proved an ultra-dependable small car with its 98% rating. The Hyundai i30 is a family-sized hatchback which came in fourth place at 97% and proved Korean cars are now a force in the marketplace.

The Which Car? 2009 report is the UK’s biggest study on car reliability. Owners were surveyed and gave their opinion on more than 84,000 modern cars. Questions were asked across the spectrum from breakdowns to minor niggles, to ascertain which cars are trouble-free and which might let you down.

Which? Car editor Richard Headland commented on the reliability of modern cars for taking trips. “Owning a reliable car can make the difference between getting your summer holiday off to a flying start and sitting on the hard shoulder of the M6. You can’t do better than the Honda Accord, which is one of the most reliable cars we’ve ever surveyed.”

More electronics, more problems?

Meanwhile despite the increase in electronic aids needed to run them, two electric hybrids made this year’s Top 10. Honda’s Civic Hybrid scored an impressive seventh place, whilst the Hollywood eco-warrior’s favourite Toyota Prius comes in at a respectable ninth.

Despite this, it turns out that electrical systems are one of the biggest problem areas identified in the survey. Manufacturers often load their cars with electronics designed to make cars more efficient, reliable and comfortable.

Why bigger isn’t necessarily better

Unfortunately for caravan fans many of the towing heavyweights made the top 10 least reliable. The Land Rover Discovery is often cited as a useful towcar with its powerful traction and strong torque from the 2.7 litre diesel engine. Yet both this model and the smaller Freelander feature at the bottom of the survey for dependability.

It’s not good news either for the Discovery’s main rival, the similarly sized Volvo XC90. The Swedish 4 x 4 may be popular with families for its seating layout and road presence, but it comes in eighth on the list of cars with the most issues.
And for those who shied away from SUVs when searching for a people carrier, the news is no better. Both of Ford’s major family cars scored poorly in the survey. The big Galaxy came in second on the list, whilst the sporty seven seater S-Max fared little better at sixth. Jaguar also bagged a brace of unwanted awards. The new award-winning XF saloon was designed to replace the outgoing S-type. Yet both feature in the top 10 least dependable vehicles on sale today in the UK.

Exceptions to the rule

Whilst Japanese cars make up the overwhelming majority of reliable cars surveyed, by no means does this form a rule of buying. The editor of Which? Car is Richard Headland, and he gave his thoughts. ‘Japanese cars in the main seem to run like clockwork, although there are a few exceptions to the rule’. These exceptions appear to be related to larger vehicles. Notably the medium-sized Japanese cars such as the Honda Civic (87%), Nissan Qashqai (87%) and Toyota Auris (86%) all fared badly in the new-car reliability rankings for 2009.

From the looks of things, it may be the case that caravan owners shopping for a new towcar will need to weigh up the any need for power against the extra electrical gremlins and niggling issues that may come with increased size. For now, it appears that in today’s car marketplace the more compact cars appear to rule the roost on reliability.

Photo gallery

Below is a picture gallery of the top 10 most reliable cars on sale today.

And the ten that propped up the bottom? We give you that list in full…

Caravans attract annual Road Fund Licence at last

During April’s budget this year Caravan Times learned of plans to introduce a Road Fund Licence for caravaners. They were unveiled to bring these road users in line with the majority of other vehicles on the road, who pay for the privilege of using the ‘Queen’s highways.’

A Treasury spokesman offered the following comment. ‘It has long been unfair that dormobiles have been subject to tax, and yet caravans have not. They damage and wear road surfaces as equally as other road users, and contribute further pollution to the atmosphere as the vehicles towing them use more fuel. It is that we wish now to redress.’. ‘We propose a Road Fund Licence for caravans levied at £295 for twelve months, or £155 for six months.’.

New buyers of the blight of ordinary motorists must pay a showroom tax of nearly £1,000 from 2010 after caravans were targeted in a further overhaul of the ‘road tax regime’.

It is reported that new caravans may be hit with a first-year levy, of £150 in addition to the Road Fund Licence. However, the new scheme, in general, is expected to reduce British motorists’ carbon dioxide emissions by more than 5%, as new sales fall.

The fiscal crackdown was announced following the recent shakeup of vehicle excise duty for cars that expands the regime by six bands to 13 from next year, creating a top M band for the highest polluting cars. Cars that emit more than 255g of carbon dioxide per kilometre, such as the Chrysler Jeep and the Porsche Boxster, will be charged an increased top rate. Those that emit less than 130g of carbon dioxide per kilometre, such as the Peugeot 207 and Fiat Panda, will pay a reduced standard rate from next year, ranging from nothing for a VW Polo BlueMotion to £90 for a Panda.

Potential buyers of large vehicles are already reacting to high pump prices and negative publicity from green campaigners, according to sales figures which show that purchases of cars in the G band fell 15% last year to 150,000. Sales of low emissions cars in bands A and B grew 17% and are expected to overtake band G vehicles this year, according to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT).

“Since the introduction of a CO2-based road tax in 2001, there has been a clear trend towards lower-CO2 new cars,” said AFD’s chief executive, Eve Paulritt, yesterday. “However, even the most non pollutant of cars, will produce more CO2 when under load, such as pulling a caravan, or trailer.”

Sir Norman Stratford, the RSAC ‘s president, has commented, however, that he believes the environmental impact of the new bands and the showroom tax would be small, following his initial report.

The Treasury said the proposals would raise an extra £1.2bn and would reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 500,000 tonnes – less than 1% of the total emitted by all drivers annually.

The Chancellor, also published the final report of a review of low-carbon cars by Sir Norman and announced a £21m research programme. The report makes 40 recommendations for caravans – ranging from colour-coded tax discs that reflect the vehicle’s weight and size, teaching schoolchildren about the environmental impact of owning a caravan, to including road transport in the European Union emissions trading regime.

It is believed that the government will make its full response to Sir Norman’s report in the summer. The Chancellor deferred a 2p-per-litre rise in fuel duty until October 2008 after pressure from motorists and haulers. Fuel duty will then rise by 1.84p per this month and a further 0.5p in 2010.

Environmental campaigners, Planet Green, have said that this was a great opportunity, and welcomed the proposal. Their press release states, “Ordinary motorists are unnecessarily buying more fuel and are not seeing any contribution from caravaners, who slow average traffic speeds on motorways and A roads to an unacceptable level, causing many an incident, on otherwise clear and popular routes. A caravan increases travelling times, inconveniences others, and takes up more space on our roads. For this, the extra pollution that caravaners are responsible for, in towing caravans, and in causing innocent others affected by their actions to be more pollutant, themselves by being stuck in traffic jams, or taking longer to complete a journey than they otherwise would expect, caravaners must pay the penalty.”

The play which is performed inside a caravan

Two years ago Britain witnessed some of the wettest weather on record, with mass flooding across the country in the summer of 2007. The Fire Brigades Union described the rescue effort as ‘its biggest ever peacetime mission’ while in some areas in Hull the water was around 6ft deep. A year after the floods, over five thousand people couldn’t return to their homes – and two thousand of those were living in caravans.

Young experimental theatre company Look Left Look Right are a documentary theatre company who reflect on the impact of the floods in their newest production The Caravan. The play is described by the company as an ‘intense and at times humourous half hour piece’ which puts both performers and audience in a 20-foot caravan.

Four cast members perform the play to eight audience members, all within the confines of the caravan itself. Written to applaud ‘the resilience of human nature’ as well as ‘give insight to how people cope in a crisis’ the choice of theatre may be considered highly unusual. Severely compromised in size with only eight people able to attend at one time, directors Mimi Poskitt and Ben Freedman believe it was the only choice.

“With The Caravan the venue is integral to the piece as a normal theatre just wouldn’t work. The audience are sitting with the performers, maybe only a foot apart, having tea with them, being asked to make space, or budge up. ”

When asked further about the insistence of using a caravan as the entire theatre rather than using a set on stage, the directors felt that realism was the key to this piece.

“It’s a very real experience, and as we’re using interviews from actual people still living in caravans it makes sense to set it in a caravan. Central to our story telling and productions are people, their experiences and their feelings. We feel that what people experienced in 2007’s floods should be reflected upon and remembered, with accuracy.”

The Guardian newspaper was full of praise for the production when the caravan was stationed outside of the Royal Court Theatre for performances earlier this year. “It is like having a chat with new-made friends over digestive biscuits.the cramped seating, the sound of rain on the roof and the enforced intimacy create a sweet directness in the piece.”

The Caravan is currently touring the country until the end of October, with full details below. More information about the play and the theatre company can be found here.

Drum Theatre Plymouth
Tues 15 – Sat 19 Sept, various performance times Tickets 01752 267 222
Website www.theatreroyal.com

Nuffield Theatre, Southampton
Tues 22 – Fri 25 Sept at 3.30, 4.15, 7, 7.45 & 8.30pm Tickets 023 8067 1771
Website www.nuffieldtheatre.co.uk

Canterbury Festival
Wed 21 – Sat 24 Oct at 2.00, 2.50, 3.40, 4.30 & 5.20pm
Tickets 01227 378188
Website www.canterburyfestival.co.uk

Caravan holidays beyond the summer months

Summer is traditionally the time for caravan holidays in the UK, but the sheer demand for taking breaks in Britain in 2009 has led to one organisation making a significant change.

The Caravan Club has responded to member’s wishes to make the most of their caravan or motorhome in all seasons of the year. This coming autumn and winter more sites will be open for longer, with a total of 80 sites open in the New Year and over 50 of those remaining open all year round.

The all-new ‘Autumn and Winter Touring’ brochure by the popular UK club is designed to tempt members out to enjoy the great outdoors at ‘unusual’ times of the year. The booklet will also contain details of attractions at some of the UK’s finest cities and heritage sites.

Sites which are new to the Caravan Club’s winter network include:

Riverside Touring Park, Betws-y-Coed, North Wales – ideal for exploring Snowdonia National Park

Harbury Fields Touring Park, near Leamington Spa in the heart of Shakespeare Country

Silverbank, Banchory, Aberdeenshire is in the Grampian Highlands. A perfect base for wildlife watching, pony trekking, fishing and golf (open until 4 January)

Littlehampton is handy for seaside and South Downs walks as well as historic Arundel.

As it happens the Caravan Club has a significant number of sites across the UK – over 6,000 hardstandings per night are available. The announcement of the winter programme has led to 1,600 more Certified Locations staying open this winter, which will provide an additional 8,100 pitches per night.

The good news is that for those unfamiliar with the rigours of winter caravanning, the Club’s guide provides the answer to any questions. Head of Sites Marketing Catherine Ford explained ‘It has some great ideas for getting out and about, as well as practical tips for problem-free winter caravanning’.

The guide is free to Caravan Club members and will be distributed to all members with the September issue of the Magazine. Non members can obtain it on request however by calling 01342 318813.

An update for the iconic Volkswagen camper

Think campervans and the iconic Volkswagen Type 2 will immediately spring to mind as the father of the genre. Beginning life as a van in 1950 it evolved into the ‘Microbus’ popular with hippies and those following the 1960s counter-culture. From surfers and musicians to adventurous families, the first ever minivan quickly gained cult status. Most recently TV chef Jamie Oliver toured southern Europe in a 1959 Volkswagen Samba with 23 windows and a Porsche engine.

With such a rich heritage in campervans in mind, Volkswagen have made updates to the modern equivalent of the Type 2 named the California.

The world debut of the new California will be at the Frankfurt Motor Show in September, but Caravan Times has obtained the first pictures ahead of the launch.

Just as the Type 2 began life as a van before evolving into an iconic camping vehicle, the California is also based on a commercial vehicle. Identical in shape and design to the seven-seater T5 multivan it builds on this platform through offering a battery of equipment for campers.

At first glance the external changes to the California are subtle, more evolution than revolution. New rear light clusters and an entirely new front use the latest Volkswagen design language seen recently in the new Polo and Golf. Sleeker door mirrors and a lashing of chrome trim dress the package. Otherwise it’s business as usual for the California.

The main changes however are under the bodywork. An all-new ESP (Electronic Stabilisation Program) is standard, alongside a very useful hill-start assist. Safety is emphasised in the new range: an emergency brake light system is introduced, along with a tyre monitor display to alert driver to any loss in pressure.

A welcome addition is Volkswagen’s Side Assist lane change system first seen in the Touareg off-roader. This warns the driver of anything in the vehicle’s blind spot.

The interior has been updated to reflect the new style of the passenger car range. In comes three-spoke steering wheels, shiny new instruments and a nifty ‘recommended gear shift’ display for slick shifting.

Touchscreen satellite navigation is also available, with a USB media-interface on offer for integration with external sources.

Last but not least Volkswagen will be offering for the first time their 4MOTION all-wheel drive system (featuring fourth generation Haldex coupling). Also introduced will be the seven-speed DSG automatic transmission which will be married to a new range of cleaner, more efficient engines. All are 2.0 litre TDI diesels with four options from 84PS to a powerful 180PS.

At this stage in time Caravan Times was unable to obtain prices and full specifications for the new California range. However we were told new models will arrive in selected Volkswagen Van Centres from January 2010.

Meet the new Land Rover Discovery 4. Is it the ultimate towcar?

The brand ‘Discovery’ in motoring terms has become synonymous with versatility. Ever since Land Rover introduced the range in 1989 the concept was to produce a car that could transport a large family in safety, while keeping with the tradition of excellence off-road that the marque is famous for.

Last year the Discovery 3 made its mark at the Camping and Caravan Club Towcar Awards, taking the award for ‘Best Towcar over 1900 kgs.’ With the Discovery 4 comprising more of an update and revision than a major departure in design, this Land Rover looks set to dominate for a while yet.

Evolution rather than revolution is the nature of the changes to the Discovery range. Upon first glance it appears little has changed from the futuristic all-new design from 2004 . A sleek two-bar silver grille and LED headlights are revisions aimed at creating a tauter, low-slung design for what is a sizeable two and a half tonne car.

The real changes can be found in the structure, interior and engines. Land Rover claim to have used over 1,500 new parts in this extensive re-design – and the key part is the new engine. The previous model carried a 2.7 litre diesel engine which occasionally struggled for performance when overtaking.

Such fears may be banished with the new 3.0-litre V6 diesel which proved popular in the new Jaguar XF and has been sourced for the Discovery 4. Impressive economy blended with strong performance was the praise levelled at the Jaguar, and similar is promised for the Land Rover. A claimed 30mpg and CO2 emissions of 244g/km will make ownership that much easier.

An upgraded suspension and less kerb weight will aid with towing even the mightiest of caravans, while the feted Terrain Response system from the previous model has had a software update. The device alters the set-up of the car’s suspension depending on the surface, a valuable aid for those hoping to pull another vehicle smoothly.

It is the interior which will turn most heads however. There are plenty of new gadgets beginning with a touch-screen multimedia setup similar to those found in Jaguars. Crucially for caravanners, this screen can display video footage from five seperate cameras on the vehicle. This gives a panoramic view around the large car and makes it that much easier to see the position of the caravan, especially when parking.

The Discovery 4 starts from £31,995. More information can be found at www.landrover.co.uk

LED lighting makes for greener Swifts

The future is bright and the future is LEDs. That’s according to Mayor of London Boris Johnson, who spoke eagerly in August of plans to install energy-saving LEDs at 3,500 traffic lights across London.

‘I’ve seen the future and it comprises these tip-top, energy-busting lights’ enthused Johnson, while he noted ‘installing these eco-bulbs will cut climate change emissions’ while also ‘save money from energy bills’.

With LED bulbs lasting around 10 times longer than standard bulbs, not only are they environmentally friendly but they happen to be good for the pocket in a recession.

This is good news for those thinking of purchasing a Swift motorhome. The Yorkshire-based caravan makers have taken the E600 series into the 21st century with technological upgrades. The Voyager and Bessacar E600 Series will be sporting LED lighting in the latest ranges to be launched at the International Caravan and Motorhome Show 2009.

Most of the lighting will be high output soft LED which gives a 70% reduction in power consumption. Battery life is therefore prolonged and it could now be realistic to power the system from a solar panel.

The changes are not only on the inside. The Voyager range sports new grey exterior trim to blend with the “sporty” metallic side walls. Meanwhile new graphics for the Bessacarr distinguish the updated model from the rest of the family.

Both ranges now sport refreshed kitchens with new stainless steel appliances including a frameless door fridge. The Voyager also comes with a microwave oven now fitted as standard.

For those who are curious to see more, the new model will be available for inspection at the International Caravan and Motorhome Show 2009. Click here for more information of how to obtain tickets for the NEC between 13-18 October.

The problem of caravan storage

At this time of year caravan sales often increase due to the clement weather. Caravan holidays are on the up in 2009 and there are more owners being registered than ever before.

Yet once the summer months have gone, arranging storage for the caravan over the winter months can prove to be more difficult than expected.

If you’re fortunate enough to have a driveway on your property, the standard for some time has been to park the caravan at your home. The benefits are obvious – your vehicle remains in plain sight while proximity to the house will deter thieves.

However it can also have a reverse effect when those holidays are taken. When the caravan leaves the drive, it can alert potential burglars that the house is empty. In addition, when left on the property there is the risk of annoying neighbours or breaking any rules which apply to the house.

The ideal solution for owners in the past has been to place the caravan on a secure storage site. This is not to say the idea is without its problems, mainly with regard to the issue of insurance.

The Caravan Storage Site Owner’s Association provide the gold standard for caravan storage and advise on safety and security. Their seal is recognised by a large number of insurers, who will sometimes not offer insurance for unapproved sites. However not every owner either desires or is able to store their caravans on one of these areas.

Adrian Flux insurance services are familiar with this conundrum. “We’ve had lots of enquiries from customers who want to store their caravans on unapproved sites because they are more conveniently located or more competitively priced than approved sites,” observed Julie Carter from the insurers. “Some of them are having problems getting quotes” she added.

It’s not all doom and gloom however. With the advent of technology such as Google Earth and Google Streetmap, it has never been so easy to assess risk in advance. Gone are the days when a cautious owner’s only option was to drive to the area and get a ‘feel’ for the place. Insurance brokers Adrian Flux have used the technology themselves to expand their cover to unapproved sites, where previously they could have declined to quote from lack of knowledge.

The best advice for owners forced to store their vehicle at an unapproved site remains simple. The use of extra security devices remains an effective deterrant to opportunist thieves. Wheel clamps, modern locking devices, and vehicle trackers are all proven to help thieves move on, and as such are also useful in reducing those insurance premiums.

Caravan holidays: Newquay

Think of Newquay and the first thing that often comes to mind is surfing. The Cornish resort is often called ‘The Surfing Capital of Britain’ and with ten sandy beaches on offer it’s no wonder tourists flock there come the summer months.
A little known fact however is that Newquay also contains an abundance of quality camping sites. Those looking for a relaxed holiday in the south west can take a caravan and experience top-class facilities.

The AA and English Tourism Council have officially graded 220 parks in Cornwall. 27 are five star, and incredibly Newquay can boast to owning a third of them.

Those on a budget will find that the quality does not significantly drop. Of the 37 parks that Newquay offers, half of them are four star accommodation or above.

According to Visit Cornwall, research from two years ago showed one in ten visitors were going to Cornwall on a camping or caravan holiday. The number is likely to have increased as reports suggest more people than ever are taking caravan holidays to counter the effects of the recession.

Tourism Newquay’s Business Development Manager is Richad Wilcox, who was delighted that the work put into improving facilities over the last few years has paid off.

‘Newquay’s accomodation offer has improved greatly over the past few years and it’s fantastic to see that we can boast a third of the South West’s top rated parks.’

If you’re curious, you can find the eight Parks with five star ratings on the official Tourism Newquay website www.visitnewquay.org.

The sites are listed below:

– Hendra Holiday Park

– Trevella

– Newperran

– Treworgans

– Sun Haven Valley

– Mawgan Porth Park

– Whiteacres

– Trevornick

New caravan site opens at Littlehampton

A new caravan site has been opened at Littlehampton ahead of schedule and in time for the summer.

The site has been opened by the Caravan Club and contains 117 pitches. There is easy access to the town centre and beach, as well as to the scenic walks along the river Arun to historic Arundel and the South Downs beyond.

The touring organisation for European caravanners put forward around £2million for acquisition and development of the site. The new caravan park is said ‘to meet the Caravan Club’s exacting quality standards’.

The site comes as a welcome addition for those who have previously enjoyed Littlehampton’s beautiful natural harbour, but struggled for lack of accommodation for their caravan.

Other attractions nearby include plenty of waterside restaurants (the East and West Beach Cafes have won awards) along with the Harbour Park amusement park for the kids.

Swift updates to popular caravan range

Award winning Yorkshire caravan makers Swift have announced updates to all three of their caravan ranges.

The Charisma, Challenger and Conqueror lines of caravans come with re-styled kitchens and updated mechanicals in response to user demands.

Loyal customers of the Charisma range had suggested updated such as high security entrance locks, thicker washroom doors and fully lined showers. All have been delivered along with improved shock absorbers in an updated model for 2009.

Those re-styled kitchens aren’t for show, and contain all new appliances across the three caravan ranges. The look is contemporary and sleek – stainless steel effect fridges compliment the granite look of the sink area. Even the control panels are all-electrical and futuristic.

Meanwhile the Challenger and Conqueror ranges sport new graphics and shiny ‘Storm’ alloy wheels to differentiate the models from the previous incarnation. Yet it’s not all show: AL-KO secure wheel locks and a AL-KO side mountable jack ensure the new purchase won’t wander too far from where it’s pitched.

£12,360 gets you the entry-level Charisma 220 with 2 berths and a length of just over 12¿, while £19,735 takes you up to the range-topping Conqueror 645 and 4 berths.

The updated ranges were shown to acclaim from customers at The Caravan Extravaganza show this September at The Lawns, Cottingham.

‘Stealth’ caravan to debut at NEC in October

Many of you will have made a note in your calendars of the International Caravan and Motor Home Show 2009, to be held at the NEC in Birmingham, 13-18 October.

At this show British caravan makers Dunster House are to launch a brand new make of caravan called the Stealth Caravans.

Competing against mainstream brands on show, the new ‘Stealth’ forms part of a range of medium to large caravans with eye-opening new layouts, interior finishes and exterior designs.

But why the name ‘Stealth’? The caravan sports a unique nose-cone, from which the Stealth name derives. The picture is a front-on view which shows off the one-piece nosecone design. Whist it sheds light on the name ‘Stealth’ with design cues from the military fighter, there are practical reasons for the oblique shape. Managing director of Dunster House Alex Murphy explained further.

“We designed this as a way of solving the problem of water ingress” he explained. “The one-piece nosecone comes up over the roof which means water naturally flows away from the caravan. On conventional designs this is not the case”.

In fact, the whole idea of the Stealth came from Murphy’s love of design combining with a new-found obsession. His company Dunster House are well known for building high-end log cabins and outdoor office spaces. So why caravans?

‘I bought a caravan a year ago and became a complete caravan nerd. I was thinking “could I design one better?” and so I wrote off to caravan brands offering free design services. I got nothing back but I come from a design background as it is so we went ahead using a caravan specialist here’.

He observed ‘I love coming up with new answers for the same old questions’.

And when the question of reliability was raised considering the youth of the Stealth brand, Murphy was quick to counter the notion. ‘I’m aware caravan design isn’t perfect, but in essence we’ve thought about things we could improve. For example, the combi-boiler is a hidden- heating system. Normally in caravans your convector heater is stuck on the wall in an open set-up. Here it’s been tucked away as part of the design’.

Furthermore design isn’t limited to the exterior. ‘We’ve produced very high-gloss, high-end finishes rather like modern kitchens. Our island bed is a first as well – no one offers it with an end washroom and twin dressing tables. Access around the bed is easier as your feet can actually go under it’.

For more information you can visit our Stealth Caravans page.

The Stealth caravan will be available to view at the International Caravan and Motorhome Show 2009 at the NEC. To book your place or tickets please visit the organisers website